Payday loans, personal loans and buy now, pay later (BNPL) services all let you borrow money or spread the cost of a purchase over time. But they differ in how much you can borrow, what you'll pay and how long you'll have to repay it. Understanding these differences can help you compare your options and make a more informed decision.
Understanding the differences is useful before comparing any form of credit on speed or convenience alone. The costs, repayment periods, fees and consumer protections will vary depending on the type of finance.
This is particularly relevant heading into Black Friday, Christmas and the summer holidays, when there are plenty of opportunities to spend. Whether you’re considering credit now or at any other time of year, the useful questions are the same: How much will it cost overall? When do you need to repay it? What happens if you miss a payment? And will the repayments comfortably fit your budget?
Let’s start with what Australians usually mean when they talk about a payday loan.
A payday loan is a type of small, short-term loan. In Australia, what’s commonly called a payday loan is generally a small amount credit contract (SACC). This describes an unsecured loan of up to $2,000 with a term of between 16 days and one year.
The name “payday loan” can be a little misleading. It doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll borrow money today and repay it all on your next payday. A SACC could run for anywhere from 16 days to one year.
With a payday loan, you apply to borrow a relatively small amount for a relatively short period. If the application is approved, you agree to a repayment schedule with the lender.
Australian law places limits on payday loan costs. A lender can generally charge:
There are also protections around repayments. Under current rules, the total required repayments under applicable small amount credit contracts generally can’t exceed 10% of your available income (more specifically your earnings after tax) during the relevant payment period.
That limit is an important protection, but it doesn’t mean a payday loan will necessarily be affordable for your individual budget. Rent or mortgage payments, groceries, utilities, transport, existing debts and other commitments still have to be met.
One of the biggest risks with payday loans is that the cost can be high relative to the small amount borrowed. Australian law limits what payday loan lenders can charge, but those limits can still result in a substantial payment. On top of this, payday lenders are not legally required to tell you the annualised interest rate, making it easy to overlook the total cost of borrowing (National Debt Helpline, 2026).
For example, if you borrowed $1,000, the maximum establishment fee would be $200. The maximum monthly fee would be $40 for each month the fee applies.
If four monthly fees applied, that would be:
$1,000 borrowed + $200 establishment fee + $160 monthly fees = $1,360 to repay
In this example, borrowing $1,000 would cost $360 in standard fees, equivalent to 36% of the amount borrowed. That's before any applicable government charges or additional costs arising from a default.
Australian law also limits how much a payday lender can recover if you default. Generally, a lender cannot recover more than 200% of the original loan amount, although court enforcement expenses may also apply. These protections don't make payday loans inexpensive, so it's important to understand the full repayment amount before agreeing to borrow. (ASIC, 2026).
The shorter repayment period can matter too. Having to repay the loan and its fees relatively quickly can take a sizable amount out of upcoming pay cycles. If your budget was already stretched when you borrowed the money, that can leave less available for rent, groceries, utilities and other essentials.
Payday loans can provide access to a small amount of credit, but there are several risks worth considering before applying. Specifically, the main risks of payday loans are the relatively high fees, short repayment periods and the possibility that borrowing under this model can make an existing budget problem harder to resolve.
Payday loans and personal loans are both forms of credit, but their amounts, terms and cost structures are different. A payday loan that meets the SACC definition is limited to $2,000 and has a term of between 16 days and one year. Outside of the amount you borrow, its costs primarily come from additional fees rather than interest like in the case of a personal loan.
A personal loan generally involves borrowing an agreed amount and repaying it in regular instalments over an agreed term. Personal loans may be unsecured or secured against an asset. Interest rates and fees apply.
| Payday loan (SACC) | Personal Loan | BNPL | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amount | Up to $2,000 | Varies by lender and product | Varies by provider and spending limit |
| Term | 16 days to 1 year | Generally longer; varies by product & lender | Varies by provider and repayment plan |
| Interest | Can't be charged on a SACC | Generally applies | Often interest-free, depending on provider |
| Other Costs | Additional fees could apply | Additional fees could apply | Late fees and other charges could apply |
| Security | Unsecured | Can be secured or unsecured | Generally unsecured |
| Repayments | Regular repayments over an agreed short-term period | Regular repayments over an agreed period | Instalments over an agreed period |
If you’re considering finance, a good place to start is to consider the amount you want to borrow, the total amount you’ll be required to repay, each repayment amount, the frequency, the terms and what happens if you miss a payment.
Yes, applying for a loan could affect your credit score and ability to borrow from other lenders in the future. This is because when you apply for finance your application is added to your credit report.
Your credit report contains information about your credit history, including credit applications, accounts you hold, repayment history and certain defaults. Credit reporting bodies use information from your credit report to calculate your credit score. When you apply for credit, a lender may request to access your credit report. This can be done in the form of a “soft credit check” or a “hard credit check”. Missed or late repayments and defaults may also be recorded in your credit.
A hard credit check is recorded on your credit report and can be seen by other lenders. Making several credit applications within a short period may also affect your credit profile.
A soft credit check is different. It doesn’t affect your credit score. Often lenders will use a soft credit check to see if you qualify or to give you a quote. At Jacaranda Finance, you can check if you qualify with no impact on your credit score*.
Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) is a type of credit that allows you to purchase something immediately and pay it back over time, usually through a series of instalments.
For example, if you bought something for $400 using BNPL, the provider might split the cost into four $100 payments over several weeks. Unlike a traditional personal loan or payday loan, BNPL is generally linked to a specific purchase at the point of sale, rather than providing you with a lump sum of money to spend.
In Australia, BNPL products are regulated under the national consumer credit framework. Since 10 June 2025, BNPL providers have been subject to credit licensing requirements, and responsible lending obligations apply. Some BNPL contracts are subject to modified responsible lending requirements, depending on how the arrangement is structured. This means BNPL isn't simply an interest-free checkout option. It's a form of credit with obligations and protections that consumers should understand before signing up.
BNPL can be convenient, but it still involves taking on debt. Don’t think of these services as “not really borrowing” simply because it appears as a payment option at the checkout. While BNPL is often advertised as interest-free, that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s free to use. Depending on the provider, you may pay an establishment fee when you open the account, an ongoing monthly account fee or a processing fee when you make payments. If you miss a scheduled payment, you may also be charged a late fee. The exact fees and limits depend on the BNPL product. Australian credit law also caps the fees that can be charged under certain BNPL arrangements. Review the contract before signing up so you know with confidence what you’re agreeing to.
BNPL can also affect your credit history. Applications may involve credit checks, and information about your BNPL arrangements or missed repayments may appear on your credit report. Lenders may consider this information when assessing future applications, including personal loans, car loans and mortgages.
Around Christmas and end-of-year sales, when BNPL can be particularly visible at the checkout, it’s worth looking past the size of an individual instalment. Consider the total cost of the purchase as well as the repayments you’re already committed to before taking on another.
No. Buy now, pay later isn’t the same as a payday loan, although both are forms of credit.
BNPL generally lets you make a particular purchase immediately and pay for it through a series of instalments. You typically won’t receive a lump sum of cash with these services. BNPL products also generally don’t charge interest, although fees can apply. This is different to a payday or SACC loan where the amount you borrow is paid out in cash and can be used for multiple transactions. Similarly to BNPL services though, SACC loans do not charge interest although fees can apply.
Before agreeing to a payday loan, personal loan, BNPL arrangement or another form of credit, it’s important to look beyond how quickly you can access it or how affordable the individual instalments are.
Check the total amount you’ll repay, all interest and fees, the size and frequency of repayments, the repayment term and any consequences of missing a payment. Then compare those repayments with the money you’ll actually have available after essential expenses and existing commitments. For a personal loan, the comparison rate can also help you compare the cost of different products because it combines the interest rate with certain fees and charges into a single percentage. However, it doesn't include every possible fee or account for your individual loan circumstances, so it's important to compare the total amount repayable as well.
And if you’re comparing lenders, check that you’re dealing with an appropriately licensed credit provider. Be cautious about anyone making guarantees about approval before properly assessing an application.
If you need money for an essential expense, taking out new credit isn’t always the only option.
Depending on your circumstances, alternatives may include arranging more time to pay a bill, asking a service provider about hardship support, checking whether you’re eligible for a Centrelink advance payment, or looking at a No Interest Loan (NILs) for eligible essential expenses. If the issue is broader than one bill, free financial counselling may be more useful than adding another repayment to the budget.
If you’re struggling to make repayments – or think you might soon – contact your lender as early as possible. You can ask about financial hardship assistance, which may include changes to your repayments or another payment arrangement depending on your circumstances.
You can also get free, confidential and independent help from the National Debt Helpline on 1800 007 007. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people can contact Mob Strong Debt Help on 1800 808 488.
If you’re considering taking out another loan to meet existing repayments, speaking with a financial counsellor first could help you understand your options before adding another repayment to your budget.
Want to keep learning? These Jacaranda guides are a useful next step:
Yes. Payday loans that meet the definition of a small amount credit contract are legal in Australia, but they’re tightly regulated. Rules apply to the fees, repayments and responsible lending obligations of these lenders.
A lender can’t charge interest on a payday loan. Instead, Australian law permits certain fees, including an establishment fee of up to 20% of the amount borrowed and a monthly fee of up to 4%.
Yes, it may be possible to get a loan with bad credit. Some lenders such as Jacaranda Finance will consider factors beyond your credit score, such as your income, expenses and current financial situation. Eligibility criteria vary between lenders.
Not automatically. BNPL and payday loans have different structures and costs. BNPL may not charge interest, but fees can apply, and repayments still need to fit your budget. Always compare the total cost and repayment commitments before agreeing to borrow.